Home  >  Ask a Lawyer  >  Indiana Criminal Defense  >  AttorneyPages Question and Answers

Does my daughter need to hire a lawyer and do the police always have to read you your right when arrested?

Question Details:My daughter went to the BMV in July and took care of outstanding fines, had her license renewed etc. She had a court date set for November 3rd to prove she had complied. She is a single mom with four kids working two jobs, she forgot to appear. She was arrested, handcuffed in front of her children, the police did not read her her rights, they would not allow her to wait til her ex-husband arrived before leaving the kids alone with only a sheriffs deputy to sit out in his car until the ex arrived. She was forced to sleep in a freezing jail cell with no blanket.

Asked 2 years ago under Criminal Defense | 725 Views | More Legal Topics

Are you an attorney? Sign up to answer this question.
M.D., Member, California and New York Bar | FreeAdvice Contributing Attorney Answered 2 years ago

When your daughter failed to appear in court a bench warrant for her arrest was issued.  Typically, for a matter such as this, the police won't actively pursue someone.  Being taken into custody generally occurs only if another offense of some kind has been committed and the warrant turns up in a background check.  Either way, however, it must be dealt with.  Unfortunately, in this case your grandchildren were subjected to the site of their mother in handcuffs.  At this point she would be well advised to retain an attorney to help her sort all of this out.

As for her not being read her rights, basically, the Miranda warning (the reading of your rights) must only be given if a person is in custody and then questioned.  Any questioning before being taken into custody is legal.  However, if a person is in fact in custody and then questioned without being Mirandized then any statements made cannot be used.  The two exceptions to this: the statements were voluntarily and knowingly made any way (ie the defendant waived his rights); or the questioning was incidental to the booking process (ie. name, address, etc). So unless your daughter was questioned after being arrested she did not have to have her rights read to her.

Top Ranking Attorneys

  • Hong Shen 210 Answers | Points 4800 Gold Contributor
  • Joseph Gasparrini 46 Answers | Points 2200 Bronze Contributor
  • Kelly Broadbent 81 Answers | Points 2000 Silver Contributor
  • Russ Pietryga 78 Answers | Points 1950 Silver Contributor
  • Shawn Jackson 17 Answers | Points 850 Bronze Contributor
  • Glenn M. Lyon, Esq. 27 Answers | Points 830 Bronze Contributor
AttorneyPages.com